Maxim Monday: Shun Murder

This is another maxim that at first glance seems so obvious as to warrant only a sentence. Yet, this maxim has several dimensions worth considering.

The most surface level is: don’t murder other people. I can say that I have never murdered anyone and have no intentions of ever doing so. Done and dusted, right? Not so fast.

Plenty of vegans and vegetarians suggest that eating meat is murder. I absolutely see that point, and I render it null and void. All creatures need to eat. Humans are omnivores. Many sages and vegans/vegetarians say that we have the karmic and conscious ability to choose not to harm other beings in our nutritional needs. But that’s not true. We have to kill something living to eat, whether that’s a rabbit, a cow, a carrot or growing grasses. We kill insects in the practice of agriculture. We step on worms and fungi and lichens when we walk outside. We are death machines, killing at every breath. I do not privilege the cow over the carrot. I do, however, privilege myself over the cow and the carrot. I don’t know how else to stay alive.

Another level to this maxim is supporting policies that do not kill other people. Let’s look at the situation in Syria. I concede that there is no good answer to that clusterfuck of a nightmare. People are dying by the thousands; it is the largest refugee crisis in a generation. If we support rebels, we are supporting killing. If we support the Assad government, we are supporting mass murders. If we do nothing, we are standing by while thousands die and will continue to die. In this situation I do not know what the right answer is, but these are the sorts of grey areas that make a maxim like ‘shun murder’ so difficult to contend with. What other policies, foreign and domestic, are full of invisible murder?

So deciding not to murder isn’t quite so easy. I may not have murdered anyone (any human) myself, but I have certainly been complicit in ways that are not so clear. This is not a grand, sweeping guilt trip. Merely a reflection that we can never be certain of every consequence of our every action. Shunning murder is harder than we might think.


2 responses to “Maxim Monday: Shun Murder

  1. Fascinating topic. It’s definitely not a simple thing, and hard to avoid murder. I absolutely agree that we are death machines- such is the definition of complexity. So many things constantly flickering in and out of existence at every second. I think people like to define things that have bigger or smaller “souls”, so we tend to make bigger, macroscopic things more dear to us and smaller things inconsequential, when in fact if we leave the windows open and then close them after a bunch of flies, moths and mosquitoes have flown in, they have maybe a day to live (with the exception of mosquitoes who have their feast in us). Our homes are boxes of insect death at all times. All you have to do is look at the window sills.

    But we don’t think twice about it, whereas some people can’t stand the act of humanely killing an animal for sustenance and/or clothing. What about all the microbes we kill when we cook our food? Don’t they deserve a chance? NO, I daresay they don’t. How about viruses? Nope, they don’t deserve to live either. People don’t like to think about micro vs macro and tend to minimize our place in the scheme of organic reality, yet they are forced to use the human perspective to evaluate what is fair, and ultimately what lives and what dies. Interesting. I guess it all comes down to taking on at least awareness of what is ACTUALLY going on and being ok with it.

    • I think so. And I don’t think I’m ‘right’ – just that I want my beliefs and actions to be as aligned as possible. Awareness of my own logical holes is part of that. If being a vegetarian helps someone be more aligned in their life, between their beliefs and actions, then good for them.

Let's discuss

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s